UPDATE : Friday, February 21, 2020
상단여백
HOME Hospital
‘Traditional Chinese medicine harmed new coronavirus control’
  • By Song Soo-youn
  • Published 2020.02.05 15:38
  • Updated 2020.02.05 15:55
  • comments 10

A U.S. magazine criticized traditional Chinese medicine for undermining efforts to prevent the spread of the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) within China.

The Foreign Policy on Monday published an article, saying traditional Chinese medicine was doing more harm than good in fighting the crisis. It slammed the Chinese state media Xinhua for promoting “pseudoscience” to the public and exacerbating the confusion. (Link to the article: Chinese Media Is Selling Snake Oil to Fight the Wuhan Virus)

The Foreign Policy’s article published on Monday criticized China’s promotion of traditional Chinese medicine in fighting the new coronavirus.

The magazine reported that Xinhua advised concerned people to try Shuanghuanglian, an oral remedy, backing up the claim with a study by the Shanghai Institute of Meteria Medica and the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

After the news report, Shuanghuanglian sold out across the country. Composed of honeysuckle flowers, Chinese skullcap, and forsythia, Shuanghuanglian is known to be effective for fever, cough, and sore throat.

However, the Chinese news report came under fire, and the popular medical information site, dxy.cn, denied the claim for Shuanghuanglian’s efficacy. Pressured by growing criticism, other state media outlets began to play down the Xinhua’s report.

“Shuanghuanglian was invented in the 1960s, based on a mixture of the fictional humoral theories that underpin pre-modern Chinese medical theories and the herbology accumulated by Chinese medical practitioners over centuries,” the Foreign Policy said. “As with most such practices, the clinical evidence is highly inconclusive. There is no evidence it can achieve success in the treatment of bacterial and viral infections, especially at scale.”

The magazine went on to say that clinical standards of traditional Chinese medicine were unclear, and data faking was common. It cited a study published in 1998 to note that 99 percent of papers in conventional Chinese medicine reported positive outcomes, which was statistically impossible.

“For poor Chinese unable to afford hospital treatment or afraid of being snatched up into quarantine, home remedies may be the only options available. But spurious herbs and imaginary theories can only harm the attempts to battle a virus that needs a scientific answer, not a politicalized pseudoscience,” the magazine said.

Oriental medicine practitioners promote Shuanghuanglian as a preventive drug for Wuhan virus

Some Korean Oriental medicine practitioners are promoting Shuanghuanglian for the treatment of the new coronavirus. An over-the-counter medication containing Shuanghuanglian is also available in the market.

An Oriental medicine practitioner said the Oriental medicine community should join efforts to prevent the spread of the new coronavirus on a blog of an Oriental medicine clinic. “A study found that Shuanghuanglian could control the novel coronavirus. Because of the findings, this drug is running out of stock,” he said.

He claimed that the drug was studied for the treatment of acute upper respiratory tract infections and that it was the most commonly prescribed drug for cold in China.

During the SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) outbreak in 2002-2003, WHO statistics showed that China’s Guangdong Province used Shuanghuanglian more actively and recorded a significantly low mortality rate compared to other regions of the country, he claimed.

Another Oriental medicine practitioner said on his blog that the novel coronavirus outbreak would be contained by Oriental medicine. “I am preparing herbal medicine to prevent the new coronavirus in advance and prescribing reimbursable and non-reimbursable medicines to patients,” the practitioner said.

The Association of Korean Medicine (AKOM), a group of Oriental medicine practitioners, demanded state support for combining Western medicine with traditional Korean medicine to treat and prevent the new coronavirus.

AKOM President Choi Hyuk-yong said in a news conference on Jan. 29 that Oriental medicine practitioners should directly see the confirmed and suspected patients and establish treatment guidelines.

To do so, AKOM needs aggressive support from the government, Choi emphasized.

soo331@docdocdoc.co.kr

<© Korea Biomedical Review, All rights reserved.>

Other articles by Song Soo-youn
iconMost viewed
Comments 10
More
  • garry helee 2020-02-20 13:32:31

    (dr.losaherbalhome@gmail .com) please sir keep your good work cause there are people out there who is in need of your healing medicine.once more email him now: (dr.losaherbalhome@gmail.com) you can call him OR WHATSSAPP HIM +2349056464736
    DOCTOR LOSA CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
    1. HIV   삭제

    • victoria janniffer 2020-02-20 04:55:51

      CURED FROM GENITAL HERPES VIRUS AFTER USING DOCTOR HAZIM HERBAL MEDICINE 
      Herbal supplements have existed for thousands of years and can be traced over several different cultures. For now. Herbs are now used to cure diabetics, herpes, chronic pain, asthma,hepatitis b, cancer , ALS , Ovarian Cyst and   삭제

      • Harry Raphael 2020-02-18 15:30:37

        FINALLY FREE FROM HERPES VIRUS
        I thought my life had nothing to offer anymore because life
        became meaningless to me because I had Herpes virus, the
        symptoms became very severe and bold and made my family
        run from and abandoned me so they won't get infected. I gave
        up everything, my hope, dreams,visi   삭제

        • Luanda Michael 2020-02-15 11:29:04

          CURED FROM HERPES VIRUS ...indeed DR HASSAN IS a God sent  Contact DR HASSAN VIAEmail :(drhassanherbscure@gmail.com).  whatsApp  /CALL +2349032582239 Website :https://dr-hassan-herbal-cure-for-herpes.business.site DR HASSAN is the only Dr who could ever get Herpes cured with his healing medicine, i   삭제

          • Bridget Helen 2020-02-14 06:22:13
          • tomkingsley 2020-02-13 10:18:28

            Are you suffering from herpes or any kind of disease and you want a complete cure contact Dr Ohikhobo through email :drohikhoboherbalcenter@gmail.com or Whatssap him +2348103601042 he is going to cure you completely instead of suppressing your outbreak with ineffective drugs he cured me since 2015.   삭제

            • Christopher Walker 2020-02-13 07:16:25

              All thank to Dr Kham for his marvelous work in my life,I was HERPES Patient, when I come across some testimony on Blogs when he also cured someone from herpes.Then I said let me contact him as well in my Case And he also help me. thank you once again. God bless you Dr Kham is a herbal Dr that can cu   삭제

              • steve 2020-02-09 12:18:43

                Battling with any health related issues or infection is not the end of your life, why not contact a herbal practitioner for cure dr Festus has herbal remedies and permanent solution for all your health related problems.I recommend him to you today only because i have also used his herbal medicine an   삭제

                • MARY 2020-02-09 12:17:48

                  Dr ogbekhilu herbal medicine is a good remedy for herpes simplex virus cure, i just want to share this article about Dr ogbekhilu who helped me, i want to inform the public how i was cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) by DR ogbekhilu , i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like   삭제

                  • Queen Sofia 2020-02-07 07:02:41

                    My name is Sofia, I want to appreciate the great work of Dr.Isai, I was diagnose of herpes disease 2years ago, and I’ve loose all hope that there is no cure, but then I was taken medication from my doctor just to sustain myself until I got to know about Dr.Isai through a friend who he cured of HIV.   삭제

                    여백
                    여백
                    여백
                    Back to Top